MUSICOLOGICAL LITERATURE OF INDIA - Part III
Dr. P. P. Narayanaswami

Carnatica Products             Rasika Forum          News-Views-Reviews          Special Features      Events Calendar

Home > Special Features


Search
Search
 

MUSIC APPRECIATION
Kutcheri, Raga, Tala, Sahitya
MUSIC HANDBOOK
Artistes, Composers, Lyrics
SPECIAL FEATURES
Tributes, Tidbits, Quizzes
RELATED SUBJECTS
Dance, Harikatha, Folk Music
SITE MAP


 

<< Part II

Chaturdandi Prakashika

Ve"nkaTamakhin, the son of GOvindAcArya, is often regarded as the grammarian (PANini) of karNATik music. His monumental work "CaturdaNDI PrakAshaika" is the base for the modern system of karNATik tradition. CaturdaNDI (four pillars) refers to four aspects of music: gIta, thAya, Alapa and prabandha. The book as extant is incomplete; only nine chapters have survived, on the topics shruti, svara, mELa, rAga, AlApa, thAya, gIta, prabhandha, and vINa (the tenth and last chapter on tALa may have been lost for ever). The book's exegesis of musical theory is both concise and precise. Ve"nkaTamakhin can be credited with the attribution of twelve svara sthAnams for seven svarams, and the classification scheme of seventy-two mELas. But he gave importance only to nineteen mELas (prasiddha mELas), namely, mukhAri, sAmavarALi, bhUpALam, sha"nkarAbharaNam, sAmanta, dEshAkSi, hejjajji, vasantabhairavi, gauLa, bhairavi, Ahiri, shrI, kambhOji, nATa, shuddhavarAli, pantuvarALi, shuddharAmakriya, simharavam, and kalyANi. Ve"nkaTamakhin only described how to construct the seventy-two mELas.  The actual names given to these mElas based on the kaTapyAdi counting scheme (KanakAmbari for mELa #1, phEnadyuti to mELA #2, …  to rasama~njari for mELa #72) was a much later invention, attributed to his descendent Muddu Ve"nkaTamakhin. There is an anubandham (appendix) to caturdaNDI that gives the names and the definitions of all seventy-two asampUrNa mEla with the janyams (derivatives) of each of these mELas. Most scholars are in agreement that this appendix segment of the work was added later by  Muddu Ve"nkaTamakhin, who might also have authored the several gItams that appear as illustrations in later works.

SangIta Saramrita

TujAja MahArajA (also known as tukkAji) was  a ruler of Tanjore during 1728-36. He was the brother the famous Maratta King Shaji and SerafOji, and the third son of EkkOji. "Sa"ngIta Saram.rta" by TulAji Maharaja is a work consisting of fourteen chapters, called prakaraNas, concerned with shruti, suddha svara, vik.rta svara, grAma mUrcchana, sadharaNa, varNalamkara, jati, gIti, mELa, rAga, vAdya, gIta, and tALa. In each chapter, the author briefly discusses details about his family, and often refers to existing classical work. He declares that nAda is the Lord paramAtma himself, and forms the base for the entire system of music. He describes varieties of nAdas such as sUkSma, atisUkSma, puSTa, apuSTa, and kritrima. He follows his predecessors very closely in providing an exhaustive description of shrutis. Just like Bharata, he describes twenty-two shrutis. The seven svarams take on the tonal values of 4, 3, 2, 4, 4, 3, and 2 (equalg twenty-two shrutis), and are named sa, ri, ga, ma, pa, dha, and ni, respectively. GrAma, mUrcchana, shuddha and kUTa tAna are also discussed. Various mELas are obtained by grouping svaras in different permutations and combinations. He also describes the seventy-two mELas propounded by Ve"nkaTamakhin, but only nineteen popular mELas are described in greater detail. A variety of rAgas, totaling 111, are given. Various instruments and the rhythmic system are also extensively discussed. On the whole, "Sa"ngIta SarAm.rta" constitutes an invaluable scholarly achievement.

Sangraha Chudamani

GOvindAcArya's "Samgraha CUDAamaNi" is considered as the last among the great works on music since ShAr"ngadEva's period, and prior to the advent of the modern era. The work is written in chaste Sanskrit, and describes the evolution of music. GOvindAcarya adopted shrutis of the sudddha svarams whose ratios to the fundamental are 1, 16/15, 9/8, 4/3, 3/2, 8/5, 27/16, and 2, and surmises that 676 ragas are possible. On the discussion of mELa, GOvindAcarya modified the system of mELakartA, introducing the essential requirement of fullness that the  ArOhaNa and avarOhaNa contain exactly seven svaras. The current nomenclature for the seventy-two mELas (KanakA"ngi, RatnA"ngi, . . . rasikapriya) can be found in this work. He also describes the Maratti work bAhattara mELakartas by LAvani V"enkaTa Rao, a Maratta composer and poet in the court of Saketa Ram Sahib who was adept in playing LAvaNi (a Marati folk style). MahA VaidyanAtha Iyer's mELa rAgAmalika (a musical composition in a garland of 72 rAgas) was influenced by LAvani Ve"nkaTa Rao's contributions. GOvindAcArya's work concludes with an index to many janya rAgams with ArOhaNa and avarOhaNa. He composed 366 lakSya gItams, seventy-two for each mELa and 294 for the various janyams of his time.

Sangita Sampradaya Pradarshini

The greatest contribution to karNATik music in the modern era can be attributed to SubbarAma DIkSitar (1839-1906). He was the grandson of BAlusvAmi DIkSitar, the illustrious brother of MuttusvAmi DIkSitar. Practicing musicians, musicologists, and writers have drawn continual inspiration from Subbarama DIkSitar's mammoth work, "Sa"ngIta SampradAya Pradarshini". Through this work, we can obtain the most authentic account of the music of the DIkSitar school. SubbarAma DIkSitar was very reluctant about the idea of sharing his music, but at the urging of A.M. CinnsvAmi MudaliyAr, a Madras Government superintendent, he finally agreed. It took more than four years for him to complete this magnum opus, a book in Telugu whose two volumes contain nearly seventeen hundred pages.

This mammoth work, is an encyclopedia that details in a very systematic fashion the type and style of music prevalent till the time of the DIkSitar School. Th work employs numerous "gamaka" symbols, printed carefully for the first time and explained clearly by the author in the introduction. The entire work is written in a mathematically precise style, and .the material is arranged sequentially according to the 72 "rAgA"nga rAga"s Each section has discussions of the various janya rAgams, commencing with a detailed description of the particular rAgam, followed by some illustrative examples, namely, shlOkams and gItams of (Muddu) Ve"nkaTamakhi, some k.rtis  of well-known composers like MuttusvAmi DikSitar, and finally a sa~ncAri by the author himself. This voluminous treatise includes seventy-six biographies of notable musical personalities, 170 lakSaNa gItams of (Muddu) Ve"nkaTamakhin, 229 compositions of MuttusvAmi DIkSitar, ten prabandhams, forty-one ciTTa tAnas of Ve"nkaTamakhin, a few pieces by various composers like ETTappa MahArAja, and Svatii TirunAL.  Also included are two huge Appendices. Appendix A contains a host of very lengthy rAgamAlikas, some by the author himself, which includes his own 72 rAgA"nga rAgamAlka, as well as sixty-one lines of RAmasvAmi DIkSitar's famous rAga tALa mAlika, (supposed to contain 108 rAgas and 108 tALas). Appendix B has 56 compositions (some very rare) from various composers including KuppusAmayya, ShrInivAsayya, mAt.rbhUtayya, TyAgarAja, and ShyAma ShAstri,. Four among the five pa~ncaratna k.rtis of TyAgaraja are given with notations, but style given here is significantly different from what is currently in vogue. (the varALi pa~ncaratnam is not featured here for some unknown reasons).

From the early 1960s until 1980, this work was translated into Tamil by the Music Academy, with the aid of a grant from Sa"ngIta Nataka Academy.  Its 1,522 pages fill five volumes.  Very recently, the first volume was translated into Kannada and published in Bangalore. An English web edition of the  entire work is in nearing completion, and what is completed can be accessed from www.ibiblio.org/guruguha/ssp.htm.

Subbarama DIkSitar wrote two more books, (I) a small introductory work, "PrathmAbhyAsa Pustakulu", where he included the noTTu svara songs  (western melodies) of MuttusvAmi DikSitar, and (ii) "saMsk.rta Andhra drAViDa kIrtanamulu". Both works are in telugu. He had projected another large work containing numerous k.rtis of ShyAmA ShAstri, padams of KSEtraj~na, and rare kritis of TyAgarAja, but he did not live to complete the work. The famous Tamil poet Subramanya Bharathi wrote an elegy on his death.

Sangita Shastra, Krama Pustak MAlika

The beginning of the twentieth century saw the emergence of an important musicologist, Vishnu Narayan Bhatkande (1860-1936). He wrote several books in Sanskrit, Maratti, and Hindi. He developed the Hindustani system of generating and classifying rAgas. His theoretical approach to the rAga, as well as his classification and musical notation of rAgas, are valuable contributions to the present-day Hindustani system of music. Among his numerous writings are "Sa"ngIta ShAstra, Krama Pustak Malika", and several textbooks. Bhatkande's contributions to the Hindusthani thATh system were similar in aim to that of the mELakartA theory of karNATik music, and he was inspired by the works of Ve"nkaTamakhin. Also, it was Bhatkande who brought into the limelight the existing versions of famous treatises such as CaturdaNDI PrakAshika, SvaramELakalanidhi, and Sa"ngIta Saram.rta, which were later published by scholarly institutions like the Music Academy in Madras.

SangIta Kalpadrumam

The advent of the modern age brings with it the contributions of Harikesanallur MuthayyA  Bhagavathar (1877-1945). An eminent composer and creator of numerous new rAgams, MuthayyA BhAgavatar wrote "Sa"ngIta Kalpadrumam" and presented it as a D.Litt dissertation to the Travancore University. The book summarizes the work of many of its predecessors from Bharata to Ve"nkaTamakhin, quoting them extensively. Of the work's two parts, only the first was published. The language is Tamil, with occasional shOkams in Sanskrit, but written in grantha script. A translation in Malayalam of the entire work (by Dr. S. Venkatasubramonia Iyer) was published in 1977 by the Kerala Bhasha Institute. The first part has eight prakaraNams (chapters), on upOdgAtam, nAda, shruti,  svara, varNAlamkara, svaraprastAra, jati, nd gIta. Part 2 (the remaining six chapters) discusses prabandha, vAdya, tALa, rAga,  nartana and vAggEyakarAdi lakSaNa. The  work forms a true treatise in every sense of the word. It contains many prastAras (exercises) for practitioners of the art of music. In his own beautiful composition, "VijayAmbikE VimalatmikE", composed in the rAga VijayanAgari (a rAga created by MuthayyA BhAgavatar), he aptly addresses the goddess VijayAmbika as the essence of music:

shruti svara grAma mUrcchanAlaMkAra

nAda janita rAga rasa bharita sa"ngIta rUpini

Each of these aspects is fully discussed by the author in this beautiful work.

SangIta Candrika

"Sa"ngIta Candrika" (1954)  a relatively recent work from Kerala by AttUr K.rSNa PiSArODy. The work is in maNipravALam (a mixture of Sanskrit and malayalam), and has 467 verses, grouped under twelve chapters (called prakAshas), on nAda, shruti, svara, vINa, grama mUrcchana. mELa, tALa varNAlamkAra, gamaka, prabandha, rAga, and gIta. The work extensively quotes its predecessors Bharata, Mata"nga, RAmamatya, and GOvinda DIkSitar, among others. Around 442 ragas and their scales are discussed, and a new scheme of eighty-four sa"nkIrNa mELas is proposed, modifying the classical seventy-two mELa scheme. This includes twelve new mELas in which the presence of two varieties of the same note (ri, ga, ma, dha) is permitted. While the names of most mELas of Ve"nkaTamakhin are retained, their serial placement is different. The scheme is extremely complex, yet very systematic. At this time, its potential is not yet realized.

Conclusion

The various milestones in the development of our rich musical system can be summarized as follows. The vEdas provided us with musical notes, and the nATyashAstra dealt with grAmas, which may be treated as a forerunner to the concept of rAga. The classical Tamil poems gave us the paNN system; b.rhaddEshi and sa"ngItaratnAkara treated the jatis (which later became rAgas), the dEshi system of music, and twenty-two shrutis. Later, RAmAmAtya explored the mELakartA concept, Ve"nkaTamakhin expounded the seventy-two mELakartas, and GOvindacArya gave them the names that are used today. Further works by other musicologists have set the standard for today's music.

Finally, it should be noted that the above listing is not complete, nor is our discussion of the material from various treatises exhaustive. Pandit V. N. Bhatkande, in his work "Music Systems of India", mentions a host of rare and valuable musicological work that were available in the libraries of H. H. The Maharaja of Bikaner,  Government Oriental Library (Mysore), Palace Library (Trivandrum), Central Library (Baroda), Library of the Maharaja of Kashi, Tanjore Palace Library, Royal Asiatic Library of Calcutta, and the Oriental Library of Madras. These scholarly treasures further enhance the richness of our musicological writings.

The following monographs offer detailed studies of the vast amount of literature on Indian musicology.

  • Bhagyalekshmy, S., Lakshanagranthas in Music.  CBH Publications, Trivandrum (1991)

  • Nijenhuis, Emmie te., Musicological Literature. A History of Indian literature. Wiesbaden: Otto Harrassowitz, (1977).

  • Bhatkande, (Pandit) V.N,  Music Systems in India,  (Journal articles, Edited by S. N. Ratanjankar,   S. Lal & Co Delhi (1984).

CONCLUDED

 


Questions or comments? Send us E-mail.
Copyright: Srishti's Carnatica Private Limited